← TruNorth

Costco vs Sam's Club

On overall TruNorth grade, Costco scores higher (Costco: B, Sam's Club: C). Both graded from public records across nine values categories.

B
Costco
59.1/100
C
Sam's Club
48.4/100

Political donations

Costco

FEC: $336K in executive political donations; partisan lean split across 16 executive donors.

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: FEC: $22K PAC donations; 58% to Republican, 42% to Democratic committees. [CA CalAccess + NY COELIG + TX Ethics adds state-level totals.] [Stanford DIME (Bonica) corroborates.] [FollowTheMoney.org adds state-level totals.]

Environment

Costco

EPA SmartWay partner — commits to measure + reduce freight transportation emissions. JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #97 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment. CDP A-List (2024) — top tier for climate disclosure and emissions-reduction action. Held by 4 ESG/SRI fund(s) (calvert, parnassus, trillium, vanguard-esg) — investor-screen positive signal.

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: water pollution violation: $90.8M in federal penalties (Violation Tracker).

Labor

Costco

104 federal penalties totaling $98.3M since 2000 (Violation Tracker).

Sam's Club

5 OSHA severe-injury reports in past 2y (0 amputations); 70 since 2015.

DEI

Costco

HRC Corporate Equality Index: 85/100 (2025) — strong LGBTQ+ workplace policies with minor deductions. JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #97 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment. HRC Corporate Equality Index 85/100 (2025) — top-tier LGBTQ+ workplace equality rating.

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: HRC Corporate Equality Index: 90/100 (2025) — strong LGBTQ+ workplace policies with minor deductions. Disability:IN Equality Index score 90/100. JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #88 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment. HRC Corporate Equality Index 90/100 (2025) — top-tier LGBTQ+ workplace equality rating.

Charity

Costco

$80M reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.03% of revenue). JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #97 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment. Drucker Institute Management Top 250 — ranked #26 (2024) on customer satisfaction, employee engagement, innovation, social responsibility, and financial strength. Fortune World's Most Admired Companies — ranked #8 (2024). Newsweek Most Trustworthy Companies in America — ranked #7 (2024).

Sam's Club

$1.73B reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.27% of revenue) via Walmart Foundation.

Animal testing

Costco

BBFAW 2024 Tier 5 — limited disclosure of farm-animal welfare programmes. Open Wing Alliance: At risk — Kirkland Signature US shell-egg cage-free transition behind schedule. [BBFAW Tier 5 · Cage-free at risk · MSC certified · ASC certified]

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: Open Wing Alliance: At risk — Great Value cage-free milestone not yet reported. MSC retail partner — Great Value canned tuna + wild-catch lines MSC-certified. [Cage-free at risk · MSC certified]

Firearms

Costco

No federal firearms license on record for this company in the ATF FFL registry — no licensed firearms dealing or manufacturing.

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: Buycott — campaigns over warehouse wages, firearm retail, supply-chain labor. [buycott]

Privacy

Costco

Costco publishes a detailed privacy policy offering consumers opt-out rights, data deletion, and a Consumer Health Data Privacy Notice stating it does not sell consumer health data; however, two federal class action lawsuits filed in October 2023 (Castillo et al. v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 2:23-cv-01548, and R.S. v. Costco Wholesale Corp., W.D. Wash.) allege Costco secretly used Meta Pixel on its pharmacy webpages to transmit patients' sensitive health information—including prescriptions, HIV status, and insurance details—to Meta, Google, and other third parties without consent, in alleged violation of HIPAA and federal/state wiretapping laws; a federal court largely allowed the case to proceed in November 2024.

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: 1 investigation by The Markup (themes: pricing). Most recent: "Walmart Charges Higher Prices in Lower-Income Zip Codes" (2023).

Executive pay

Costco

CEO-to-median-worker pay ratio 283:1 (median employee pay $49,186) — SEC proxy statement (DEF 14A, 2025).

Sam's Club

Via parent company Walmart: CEO-to-median-worker pay ratio 958:1 (median employee pay $30,520) — SEC proxy statement (DEF 14A, 2026).

Compare any two brands on the values you care about — personalized to your 30-second quiz.

Open TruNorth →