Liberty Mutual vs Nationwide
On overall TruNorth grade, Nationwide scores higher (Liberty Mutual: D, Nationwide: C). Both graded from public records across nine values categories.
Political donations
FEC: $25K PAC donations; 86% to Republican, 14% to Democratic committees.
FEC: $35K PAC donations; 76% to Republican, 24% to Democratic committees.
Environment
Insure Our Future 2024 scorecard: 1.5/10 (weak). Sub-scores: coal underwriting moderate; oil & gas underwriting very-weak. Liberty Mutual: 2020 coal phase-out targets but no meaningful oil and gas restrictions; remains a top US insurer of the fossil-fuel sector.
No public record found.
Labor
209 federal penalties totaling $67.0M since 2000 (Violation Tracker).
131 federal penalties totaling $244.7M since 2000 (Violation Tracker).
DEI
No public record found.
No public record found.
Charity
$40M reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.09% of revenue) via Liberty Mutual Foundation. Operates the Liberty Mutual Foundation Inc: $52.2M in charitable contributions, gifts & grants paid (FY2023, IRS Form 990-PF).
$35M reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.17% of revenue) via Nationwide Foundation. Operates the Nationwide Foundation: $39.9M in charitable contributions, gifts & grants paid (FY2023, IRS Form 990-PF).
Animal testing
No public record found.
No public record found.
Firearms
No public record found.
No public record found.
Privacy
No public record found.
State regulator action: NYDFS (most recent 2024-02-27). Consent Order to Nationwide Group
Executive pay
NAIC Complaint Index 1.34 (well above the 1.00 US peer average). MA DOI: $2.7M MA Division of Insurance penalty — failure to honor mandated rate refunds during COVID-19 declared emergency.
NAIC Complaint Index 0.78 (well below the 1.00 US peer average).
Compare any two brands on the values you care about — personalized to your 30-second quiz.
Open TruNorth →