Liberty Mutual vs Progressive
On overall TruNorth grade, Progressive scores higher (Liberty Mutual: D, Progressive: B). Both graded from public records across nine values categories.
Political donations
FEC: $25K PAC donations; 86% to Republican, 14% to Democratic committees.
No FEC PAC contributions on record.
Environment
Insure Our Future 2024 scorecard: 1.5/10 (weak). Sub-scores: coal underwriting moderate; oil & gas underwriting very-weak. Liberty Mutual: 2020 coal phase-out targets but no meaningful oil and gas restrictions; remains a top US insurer of the fossil-fuel sector.
JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #22 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment.
Labor
209 federal penalties totaling $67.0M since 2000 (Violation Tracker).
76 federal penalties totaling $107.0M since 2000 (Violation Tracker).
DEI
No public record found.
JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #22 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment. HRC Corporate Equality Index 100/100 (2025) — top-tier LGBTQ+ workplace equality rating. Bloomberg Gender-Equality Index member (2024) — transparent on female leadership, equal pay, inclusive culture.
Charity
$40M reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.09% of revenue) via Liberty Mutual Foundation. Operates the Liberty Mutual Foundation Inc: $52.2M in charitable contributions, gifts & grants paid (FY2023, IRS Form 990-PF).
$25M reported corporate giving in 2024 (~0.04% of revenue) via Progressive Insurance Foundation. JUST Capital JUST 100 — ranked #22 of Russell 1000 (2025) for treatment of workers, customers, communities, environment.
Animal testing
No public record found.
No public record found.
Firearms
No public record found.
No public record found.
Privacy
No public record found.
CFPB consumer complaints: 233 on record; 87% timely response rate.
Executive pay
NAIC Complaint Index 1.34 (well above the 1.00 US peer average). MA DOI: $2.7M MA Division of Insurance penalty — failure to honor mandated rate refunds during COVID-19 declared emergency.
NAIC Complaint Index 0.94 (near the 1.00 US peer average). CA DOI: $24M settlement — Progressive failed to refund pandemic-era premium overcharges to California auto-policy customers in line with Bulletin 2020-3.
Compare any two brands on the values you care about — personalized to your 30-second quiz.
Open TruNorth →